Something that I've been wanting to add to the front page with the six existing buttons we have (official forum, policies, admins, etc) is a button to all of the help and resources offered by members of the community that new players might never know exist until/unless they just happen to hear about them. An example of what I'm talking about is the chathead blog, where editors can request edits to chatheads and there's a whole group of people helping out.
The way I imagine I would do this is to create a Wikia Resources category to collect all of the applicable pages and direct the button there. So, that begs a few more questions...
What else should be listed as a wikia resource?
Symmetry looks good. Should I replace one of our existing six buttons or add three new buttons instead of just one?
If I should replace one, which should I replace? If I should add more buttons, what do you suggest for the other two new buttons?
Update: I made the category and changed some of the buttons. You can see what's in the category now right here. I'm still open to suggestions for what else to add.