Talk:Icyene/@comment-5939245-20140115000351/@comment-5939245-20140115023341

Three others than me have posted. Claire, the first one to reply, actually agrees that it should not be here. Tiddles has not readily affirmed his position, but I'll assume he's for the Godless category staying, so that puts us at 2-2. Hardly a sample size.

As I have said Kinglink, we shouldn't be adding the Godless category because there is one confirmed Godless. If we did that, by the same logic, we would categorize the human page as "gods" because we have one confirmed human god - maybe there's more, like Tumenken or the Fremennik gods, but no conclusive proof is given for that.

There is a difference between disobeying a superior and completely betraying them. Going against the wishes of Saradomin does not make one wholely against him entirely; it merely means that in that situation, they did not support him 100% and went against his wishes.