User blog comment:SsVivid/Wordmark Logo Discussion/@comment-4835297-20130504012353

II'll try to put in some feedback for all of the categories.

Copycats: I don't really like these. I personally think a completely custom logo would be better for this wiki. It'd give it more of a personality (but for websites, so websitanality?). I think this wiki should create its own theme. While the RuneScape logo is very noticable, I don't think you should go that way, unless maybe the whole of the wiki design is copied from the RS website.

Aconyms: I don't really like these ones that much either. A lot could be applied from my previous paragraph. I also think that the logo should spell out "RuneScape (or RS) Roleplay Wiki", and not just the acronym. I do like the basic idea of the logo though, it has the familiar feel, but with its own splash of originality.

Plain Text: These ideas are probably my favorite. They're simple and effective, and most Wiki pages use similar ones. 7 and 8 stand out nicely, and with an appealing font flow. I really like how the word "Roleplay" is emphazised, drawing out the theme for this wiki. 13, 14, and 15 don't really look that appealing in my opinion. 14 especially, as it's a bit harder to read. I think a smaller object to the side or in the background may look decent. Maybe a sword underlining it all, or a pair of swords crossing in the background. I'm having a hard time picturing it, but there are endless possiblities; maybe even a helmet or a mug of beer to the side.

Symbols: These are my least favorite. I'm against the idea of not having the wiki title in the logo. I don't know if I like the asterisks either. I don't find them very appealing, even though they're a pretty creative way to resemble RS roleplaying. Perhaps if there was less emphasis on them?

Swords: I like this idea, but none of the examples really do the job. I don't think the sword used is very attractive. I like 10, 11, and 12 the best, as they show the full title. I think 13's actual sword is much better. I think the words "RuneScape Roleplay" need to stand out more than the word 'Wikia".

Sword in Stone: I don't like the idea of this. As someone mentioned below, the asterisk looks kind of like a pile of logs. It really just doesn't look like it would be a logo title, probably because of its vertical shape. The wiki title is very hard to read as well.

Dragon: I like this logo. It's more simplistic but still appealing. Like Vivid said, it may look better with a transparent background and a different font.

I hope some of this was helpful in some way.