Talk:Guildmaster Pegasus/@comment-11555902-20140607235127/@comment-11555902-20140608043346

I'm afraid you are mixed up in more than one areas of understanding from what you stated.

1. Yes, Carl Orten is 86, HOWVER he is a nearly 3 year old Character (And not even human. Which makes a difference there too.) Not 3 month. I actually roleplayed with this character quite a bit, in several public roleplays long before he even joined TSG. Carl has real history behind him. Not all it was pre-determend.

2. Yes, the creator chooses their character, however things like Argorrek is more of a public type creature, no one really roleplays as that in the community, not like you would your character, thus it needs that history behind it, the difference is your character is public and single player controled. Your supposed to have more roleplayed history.

3. There is a big difference between what you are doing and what the rest have been. What you doing is story writeing, what everyone else is doing is roleplaying. There is a difference.

You are right, this is likely to not change your chances for nomiation, however, everyone is going to know that this was pulled out of your head, rather than pulled out of the game

If you are so confident in your characters legitimacy, I challenge you to ask Joe M Jr or Dion Magnan to review this page, and ask them what the think of it.

Anyone could start making a 10 page paper about a character they made up a week ago about all his achievements and history and really gloss up how great he looks. However does that make him legit.

/Continued/